Hugo Southwell full-back – 5
Keen to come into the line, always looking for openings but never seemed to find them. When did get a sniff, he tossed the ball straight into touch.
Sean Lamont wing – 4
Bumped off Hartley as though he was made of gutta-percha, but for all his strength he showed all the penetration of a blunt butter knife.
Nick De Luca centre – 6
Brought in for his tackling, added considerable incisiveness and power to the Scotland midfield in attack. Robinson finally got his midfield selection right.
Graeme Morrison centre –7
Made a glorious dump tackle on Monye, and showed a lot more crash, bang and wallop going forward than he had in previous championship outings.
Max Evans wing – 6
Saw a lot of the ball, but never made more than a half-break. So small and slight that he spent a lot of time being tossed around like a rag doll.
Dan Parks scrum-half – 5
Made two of the most embarrassingly wayward drop-goal attempts you'll ever see. The control shown against Wales a distant memory.
Chris Cusiter (capt) fly-half – 6
Bossed, cajoled and harried his team as a captain, standing up to Borthwick. Snappy around the fringes and quick in delivery, he outshone Care.
Allan Jacobsen prop – 4
Quick hands to put De Luca through a gap, but had a torrid time at the scrum, consistently failing properly to bind, which led to a series of collapses.
Ross Ford hooker – 5
Seemed to get mixed up with some of the calls at the lineout, but had a fair afternoon despite that. Got up Hartley's nose. Not that that's too hard to do.
Euan Murray prop – 4
Should be cornerstone for the entire Scotland scrum, but he seems a little way off his best. As it was, he kept parity with the men opposite him, but no more.
Jim Hamilton lock – 4
Gave away a moronic penalty at the start of the second half, gifting England three points. A big man, but fails to make enough of an impression in the loose.
Alastair Kellock lock – 5
Steady in the lineout, which has been the best in the championship, but spent too much time hidden in the mess of bodies around the breakdown.
Kelly Brown flanker – 7
Made an absolute nuisance of himself all match long, wrecking England's possession and scything down their runners at close quarters.
John Barclay Flanker – 6
England must have been tipped off by his barnstorming brilliance in the past three matches. They kept a tight rein on him, so not as dominant as he can be.
Johnnie Beattie No8 – 8
England kept Barclay quiet, but that only made more room for Beattie. Put his head down to thump his way down the centre time and again. Man of the match.
