Robert Kitson, Andy Bull, Mike Averis, Owen Gibson, Michael Aylwin, Paul Rees 

Rugby World Cup 2015: Guardian writers’ teams of the tournament

New Zealand ruled and Argentina and Japan thrilled, but who has made the starting XV’s for our rugby writers who covered the tournament?
  
  

Dan Carter and Richie McCaw
Dan Carter and Richie McCaw may have won the World Cup, but how many writers picked them in their best XV? Photograph: Tom Jenkins for the Guardian Photograph: Tom Jenkins/The Guardian

Robert Kitson

Robert Kitson's team of the tournament
Robert Kitson’s team of the tournament

New Zealand supply more than half the XV even without Ben Smith, Julian Savea, Kieran Read and Jerome Kaino. That is tough on Smith but Japan’s technical excellence had to be acknowledged. It is tough, too, on Australia’s inside centre Matt Giteau. Both Leone Nakarawa and Taulupe Faletau would help make a top-quality bench. Have your say on our readers’ poll

Andy Bull

Andy Bull's team of the tournament
Andy Bull’s team of the tournament

Juan Imhoff switches wing because Santiago Cordero had a stinker in Argentina’s semi-final against Australia. Ben Smith just pips Ayumu Goromaru and Gareth Davies just squeezes in at scrum-half – or else there wouldn’t have been a European player in the team.

Mike Averis

Mike Averis's team of the tournament
Mike Averis’s team of the tournament

A braver man might have gone for Tonga’s Telusa Veainu or Canada’s DTH van der Merwe for Santiago Cordero, if only to reflect the role of second-tier nations in making a top-notch seven weeks.

Owen Gibson

Owen Gibson's team of the tournament
Owen Gibson’s team of the tournament

A strong All Blacks and Wallabies bias, but how could there not be? Over the course of the tournament they were the two best teams. But Argentina and Japan, who also lit up the tournament, demand representation too.

Michael Aylwin

Michael Aylwin's team of the tournament
Michael Aylwin’s team of the tournament

There are two ways of doing this – pick the best team, which would basically be New Zealand with a few others, or a team that tells the story of the tournament. This team tries to do the latter.

Paul Rees

Paul Rees's team of the tournament
Paul Rees’s team of the tournament

Would have been a different team after the pool stage, but New Zealand timed their run perfectly. No Six Nations players but Mark Bennett, Greig Laidlaw, Robbie Henshaw, Sean O’Brien, Anthony Watson, Gareth Davies, Sam Warburton and Louis Picamoles all left an imprint on the tournament.

 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*