The New York Jets’ rocky 2024 campaign has been shaped by unorthodox decision-making, including owner Woody Johnson reportedly relying on Madden NFL video game ratings to evaluate players.

According to the Athletic, Johnson vetoed a trade for wide receiver Jerry Jeudy last offseason, citing the player’s low Madden rating. Jeudy was later dealt to the Cleveland Browns, where he has thrived with 1,052 receiving yards, ranking fifth in the NFL.

The Jets also signed free-agent guard John Simpson despite Johnson’s initial opposition based on his low “awareness” rating in the game. Simpson has since performed solidly, but the team has struggled to a 4-10 record.

The Athletic cited sources within the organization that said Johnson’s teenage sons, Brick and Jack, have influenced team decisions. The owner has reportedly referenced their opinions, often based on online chatter and video game metrics, in meetings with executives and coaches.

“When we’re discussing things, you’ll hear Woody cite something Brick or Jack read online that’s being weighed equally with staff opinions,” an unnamed Jets executive said.

A Jets spokesperson denied the sons’ influence, calling their input a “reference point”. However, insiders described instances where Brick and Jack handed out game balls in the locker room, leaving players and staff uncomfortable.

The dysfunction has reached a peak this season. After a 1-3 start, Johnson reportedly suggested benching quarterback Aaron Rodgers, though the veteran remained the starter. Midseason firings of head coach Robert Saleh and general manager Joe Douglas followed.

Rodgers has underperformed and the Jets appear headed for a rebuild. Critics say the team’s reliance on unorthodox input has contributed to its struggles.

“It was the most awkward, cringe-worthy situation I’ve been part of,” one player said of the locker room atmosphere.

The team’s future remains uncertain as it considers moving on from Rodgers and rebuilding its leadership structure.